Choosing the right school hot water systems means balancing energy use, installation costs, hygiene, reliability and the needs of different facilities.
Schools can choose between point-of-use hot water heaters, which heat water close to the tap or appliance, and centralised systems, which heat and distribute water from a shared source. Point-of-use systems can reduce heat losses from long pipe runs, while centralised systems can be more suitable for facilities with high or concentrated demand. Many schools may benefit from a combination of the two.
Choosing the right school hot water system means balancing energy use, installation costs, hygiene, reliability and the needs of different facilities.
School water heaters– key concerns
According to the Department for Education maintained schools and academies in England spent around £1.2 billion on energy in the 2023/ 24 school year Recent political events have driven up energy bills and this has meant some schools have had to divert money put aside for repairs and upgrades, cut spending on the library or even freeze recruitment.
While schools are on a quest to deliver net zero, they are often deterred by high upfront costs of replacing existing arrangements with more efficient systems that are not dependent on fossil fuel. While these will reduce overall energy demand and lead to lower long-term operational costs, schools need to weigh up initial charges and possible disruption to learning.
Signs of an ageing infrastructure
A common problem is pipework that is failing. Oldham Council discovered that the copper pipework at Horton Mill Community Primary School was corroding from the inside out, forming pinholes that led to leaks throughout the school. They soon realised that the pipework had corroded, ‘beyond the point that any remedial action’ could be taken. They also noted that some of the point-of-use water heaters were approaching the end of their useful life and if not replaced, risked contaminating any newly installed pipework which would lead to the closure of the school.
- Keep a close eye on the state of the buildings and beware the risks of delaying necessary work.
How hot should hot water be?
The Department for Education states:
- To avoid the risk of scalding, 43ºC is generally the maximum temperature for hot water in baths and showers, and in all cases where the occupants are severely disabled. It is also good practice to limit hot water supplies to washbasins in nursery and primary schools to 43ºC.
- Distribution temperatures and legionella controls need to comply with HSE guidance on managing
- in hot and cold water systems.
- Where temperature is used to control the risk, hot water should be stored above 60°C, hot water distribution should be above 50°C and cold water storage and distribution should be below 20°C. Infrequently used outlets should be flushed out regularly and showerheads de-scaled and cleaned. (https://www.hse.gov.uk/healthservices/legionella.htm)
Impact on costs
To meet peak demands and meet the regulations to combat legionella schools increasingly are finding themselves caught between costly, oversized heat pump installations or direct electric systems with high operating- cost.
When heat pumps reach required flow temperatures (+55°C), some will need to work harder. If this happens, they burn more energy and this increases the costs.
What hot water systems for schools are available?
Point-of-use (POU) water heaters provide hot water close to the outlet, often through compact electric heaters installed beneath or beside washbasins.
- Short delivery routes and less heat lost through long distribution pipes.
- Useful for isolated basins, small facilities and outlets used intermittently.
- Can avoid the need to maintain a large central distribution network.
- Multiple units may increase electrical demand, maintenance points and the number of appliances to manage.
- Installing multiple electric heaters may increase peak electrical demand. Calculate this rather than estimating it.
- Consider whether reducing unnecessary water flow can also reduce the energy required to heat water
Centralised hot water systems generate and potentially store hot water centrally before distributing it through pipework to multiple outlets.Can serve clusters of outlets and areas with substantial or simultaneous demand.
- May be appropriate for kitchens, showers and specialist facilities.
- Can simplify provision where outlets are close together.
- Storage and distribution pipework can create standing heat losses, and the system needs suitable circulation, controls and maintenance.
- Long pipe runs and circulating hot water can waste energy, particularly where outlets are rarely used.
Point-of-use or centralised hot water systems?
| Consideration | Point-of-use | Centralised |
| Installation costs | Individual units may be relatively inexpensive, but costs increase when many are needed. Electrical upgrades may be necessary. | Higher initial investment in plant, storage and distribution pipework, particularly in larger buildings. |
| Energy efficiency | Can reduce distribution heat losses and avoid heating water unnecessarily in large systems. | Can be efficient for concentrated demand, but storage and circulation create standing heat losses. |
| Running costs | Electricity costs can be high, particularly where numerous heaters operate frequently. | Depends on heat source, storage, controls and distribution losses. |
| Maintenance | Multiple individual heaters mean more appliances to inspect and maintain, although individual failures may be easier to isolate. | Fewer central appliances, but faults can affect several facilities and require specialist maintenance. |
| Space requirements | Compact units can be installed close to outlets, reducing the need for large plant rooms. | Requires space for plant, storage vessels and associated equipment. |
| Best suited to | Dispersed washbasins, isolated outlets and areas with intermittent demand. | Kitchens, showers, sports facilities and clusters of outlets with substantial or simultaneous demand. |
One important qualification: neither system is automatically cheaper or more energy efficient. Performance depends on the number of outlets, usage patterns, equipment sizing, energy source and pipework design.
However, it is not a simple choice. Centralised hot water systems do not automatically mean gas-fired boilers. Point-of-use does not automatically mean the lowest energy consumption. There are many variables. The heat source, storage capacity, controls, pipework and usage patterns all influence performance. The article The Pitfalls of Decentralising Electric Water Heating in Schools discusses some of the arguments in more detail.
The Department for Education’s estate energy-efficiency guidance specifically recommends point-of-use heaters where long pipe runs would otherwise be needed, alongside pipe insulation, suitable controls and monitoring.
Hybrid hot water systems might be the answer
Hybrid can provide tailored solutions, so some areas are point-of-use while those areas with a higher demand for hot water draw from a centralised system.
The Department for Education (DfE) currently recommends a variety of approaches to water heating, with centralised systems for catering functions which represent a large, individual demand of hot water. In addition, ‘design and installation shall prioritise the use of local non-storage (or low storage) ‘point-of-use’ electric water heaters. This is to reduce standing losses from centralised hot water systems and to prevent pipework heat loss, increasing the risk of overheating.’
Riverside Primary School – why hybrid worked better
One school which has chosen hybrid is Riverside Primary School in Perth, Scotland’s first Passivhaus-accredited primary school. The school prioritises energy efficiency and minimal heat loss and has achieved impressive results. With an energy assessment of just 43kWh·m–² per year, the school, designed by Architype, is significantly outperforming the Passivhaus target of 60kWh·m–² per year.
POU had led to significant energy savings and worked well in teaching spaces. However, the nursery needed considerably more hot water for longer periods. The electrical energy use associated with the nursery was significantly higher because of the number of POU water heaters. This was having a negative impact on the building’s overall energy efficiency.
David Coulter, associate engineer and certified Passivhaus designer at BakerHicks (Motherwell), found that transitioning to a centralised hot water system could offer huge benefits. ‘As the area contained appliances within a short distance, the centralised approach provided a saving against standing losses, reheat times and other factors.’
- Make sure you assess individual areas accurately rather than estimating.
Riverside case study https://www.cibsejournal.com/case-studies/tapping-into-efficiency-passivhaus-schools-point-of-use-water-heaters/
Keep evaluating the school’s needs

Centralised hot water systems
Schools often evolve over time with changing catchment areas, expansion plans or falling rolls which may lead to change of use. in recent years there have been government initiatives to open new nursery provision, to bring more children with additional needs into mainstream
A new school may have a phased entry of pupils so the school will not be fully occupied for several years. Point-of-use heating systems have several obvious advantages here as the school will only heat the water being used. However, once it has its full complement of pupils and all parts of the building are in use, point-of-use hot water systems may not be the best option.
Extensions and refurbishments offer an opportunity for reflect on whether to extend an existing central system or install separate local heaters
Even if the overall floor area does not change, the configuration of rooms may be different. Rooms may be enlarged or divided to meet changing needs. This is especially true in schools serving areas of deprivation or where there are a high number of children with additional needs. Some schools have turned redundant classrooms into small offices for one to one work, therapeutic interventions or interviews with professionals from health and social services.
It is important that estate managers regularly audit whether their point-of-use water sources are still in the right place and whether their centralised system is still an efficient use of energy.
- Assess whether a heat pump, solar PV or another low-carbon option is appropriate for the school’s hot water demand.
Rethinking hot water systems for a school
Comberton Village College is a large secondary school in Cambridgeshire. The school has many buildings of various ages. Most of them were built as self-contained units, complete with their own plantrooms. The campus has no gas supply, so buildings were heated by oil others by liquefied petroleum.
Currently, the system is designed to operate year-round at 65°C. While the demand for heating is lower in summer, there is a swimming pool, and the system supplies hot water to calorifiers throughout the site. This means that the domestic hot water temperature needs to remain above 60°C to manage the domestic hot water quality
One incidental benefit of replacing the large, ageing fossil fuel-fired boilers with much smaller heat exchangers is that it has made maintenance much easier. See the whole case study at https://www.cibsejournal.com/case-studies/case-study-comberton-village-college-heat-network/
- Compare servicing requirements, expected equipment life, accessibility and the cost of
replacing individual units
Keeping up with increasing demand

School hot water system at Archbishop Isley School
Sports facilities have exceptionally high water requirements. The sports centre at Archbishop Ilsley Catholic School in Acocks Green, Birmingham is not just used by pupils; it is also used by the community. With increasing needs for water, day and evening, for the swimming pool, sports hall, gymnasium, and changing areas, the school decided on an extensive heating and hot water overhaul. The school replaced outdated non-condensing systems with five condensing boilers combined with a condensing water heater. Now they have an efficient high-volume system capable of keeping pace with heavy peak usage while lowering carbon footprints.
- Consider timers and controls that match use patterns, while maintaining safe water management.
Discussions for suppliers and contractors and schools
- What is the school’s actual hot water demand? Ask how the proposed system has been sized against outlet numbers, flow rates, peak periods and usage profiles.
- What are the estimated annual energy costs? What was included in the calculation: demand, standing losses, controls and energy tariffs?
- How will outlet temperatures and scald risks be controlled? Confirm the arrangements for TMVs and the relevant outlet requirements.
- How will the system manage periods of low use? Ask about water turnover, circulation, stagnation risks and holiday shutdown procedures.
- Will the existing electrical supply and pipework be adequate? Ask if upgrades will be required before accepting a quotation.
- What happens if a heater or other component fails? Understand the consequences for the rest of the school and whether backup capacity is required.
- What maintenance is required? Request a schedule covering servicing, inspections, temperature monitoring and replacement parts.
- What is included in the installation price? Check removal, disposal, pipework, electrical work, commissioning, certification and making good.
- How much of the work will be done in termtime and how do they plan to minimise disruption?
- Ask for their work in another school of similar size or which faces similar issues. Contact the school for a reference, performance data and feedback from the school’s estates team.
Extending or replacing or an existing hot water system is a major job and the technology will have advanced considerably since the existing system was installed. Point-of-use heaters can be effective for dispersed, low-demand outlets, while centralised provision may suit areas with concentrated demand. A hybrid arrangement may offer the best solution for schools especially if there are several sites with different hot water demands and usage patterns.
It is important that the suppliers and contractors understand the school’s needs and that together they work out a brief that covers installation costs, energy consumption, reliability and maintenance over the system’s lifetime.
Frequently asked questions about school hot water systems
What is the best hot water system for a school?
There is no single solution for every school. Point-of-use heaters can be suitable for dispersed washbasins and outlets with intermittent demand, while centralised systems may be more appropriate for kitchens, showers and facilities with high or simultaneous demand. A hybrid system combining both approaches can offer greater flexibility.
Are point-of-use water heaters more energy efficient?
They can be, particularly where outlets are widely distributed and a centralised system would require long pipe runs. Local heaters reduce distribution heat losses and only heat water where it is needed. However, installing numerous electric heaters can increase electricity consumption and peak demand. Their efficiency depends on how frequently they are used and how well they are sized.
Are centralised hot water systems cheaper to install?
Not necessarily. A centralised system requires a plant room, storage equipment and distribution pipework, which can make initial installation expensive. However, where several outlets are close together and have substantial demand, one appropriately sized system may be more economical than installing multiple individual heaters. Schools should compare whole-life costs rather than equipment prices alone.
Can a school combine point-of-use and centralised hot water systems?
Yes. A hybrid arrangement can use point-of-use heaters for low-demand or isolated outlets, with a centralised system serving facilities such as kitchens, showers and changing rooms. Riverside Primary School in Perth provides an example of this approach, with different arrangements selected for its teaching spa
Further information
Unlocking Hidden Energy & Cost Savings in UK Schools: https://www.iesve.com/discoveries/view/55548/dfe-school-savings
Horton Mill Community Primary School – https://committees.oldham.gov.uk/ieDecisionDetails.aspx?Id=4736
Legionella – https://www.hse.gov.uk/legionnaires/hot-and-cold.htm
Limescale protection in school electric hot water systems – https://schoolbuilding.org.uk/heating-ventilation/limescale-protection-in-school-electric-hot-water-systems/
Free audit https://schoolbuilding.org.uk/heating-ventilation/free-audit-on-all-energy-costs-for-hot-water-delivery/
How Often Should Electrical Installations Be Tested in Schools?
Checking electrical installations: https://schoolbuilding.org.uk/latest-news/how-often-should-electrical-installations-be-tested-in-schools /

